The Space Toast Pages

Matthew Rasmussen's journal of journals on various topics of interest, published here, there or somewhere since 1999.

UI: R. Clayton Miller's 10/GUI

File Under: /web/design

Problems:

1. You just doubled the amount of space I need between myself and the monitor.

2. Multitouch allows for more kinds of interaction: true! However, this interface steals ALL of them away from use by the applications.

3. Left and right sides of the screen aren't discoverable. Might as well be top and bottom -- i.e. bottom of the screen for application launching (call it a "dock") and top of the screen for context-specific options (a sort of "bar" of "menus").

4. Linear spatial overload of windows is no better than two-dimensional spatial overload of windows. Labelled zoom-all-the-way-out cheat no better than Expose and application switcher.

5. Where does file management fit into this scheme?

Lukas Mathis calls 10/GUI "one of the most dramatic reimaginations of the desktop user interface I've seen in a long time" but on examination it's an incremental hardware update with no real interface breakthroughs. Keyboard + mouse has gone on for far too long, as has the W.I.M.P. interface. A better direction would be a tactile multitouch surface which can be anything it needs to be, including a keyboard (for any language), coupled with a GUI that represents tasks and actors rather than objects in a space. 10/GUI does nothing about window and document clutter, squinting, scanning large lists, or making the computer's workings and status an organic part of its presentation. The video may be a slick investors' reel, but shows no real progress.

10.12.2009 23:00

>Run Fight Magic

>HP: 1


>The Travis hits!

>Cute name (see tenugui). But a very poor idea, for many reasons. Suffice it to say, I'm already frustrated with the number of 'gestures' I need to use to get my iPhone to work right. I have no interest in being forced to use a multitude of gestures to do various things.. two fingers for this kind of movement, three fingers for this kind of movement... it's horribly unintuitive. And besides, how are you supposed to type with this touch pad in the place of your keyboard?


Add Comment:

Name:

URL: (optional)

Comments:

If human, please enter the number eleven: (+2 armor against spam bots)